The Philadelphia Eagles hosted the Cleveland Browns and Kellen Winslow in the first National Football League game of the 2006 season at Lincoln Financial Field in South Philly. After the first pre-season game where the Eagles starters looked sharp on both sides of the ball the question of the off-season are being answered while panic and prayer are setting in over injuries. For most of the teams in the NFL this weekend is the start of their pre-season, but for the Eagles this is their second game in only five days.
Thumbs Up
The Receivers
Hank Baskett won the hearts, minds, and hopes of all fans in Philadelphia who considered the trade featuring him for Billy McMullen, a nothing for nothing deal. Baskett is the biggest surprise in training camp so far, showing that not only can he make the team but also get substantial playing time. On the first drive Baskett caught two passes from Donovan
McNabb, one of which was a 33 yard pass that couldn’t have been better received by the rookie from New Mexico. Along with Darnerien McCants’ wide open 32 yard touchdown pass from Jeff Garcia, the receivers had quite a nice night. A large worry coming into the season is the receivers and if they have enough talent and quickness for an effective offense. What the pre-season has proved thus far is that under Andy Reid’s system an these receivers can be extremely effective if they continue to catch and hold on to the ball and if McNabb continues to hit them with short accurate passes.
Jeff Garcia
Jeff Garcia has been relatively disappointing since being acquired in the off season. He is not having a particularly good camp and suffered horribly in the Hall of Fame game going five for 10 for only 43 yards and an interception. He was off target with his passes and jittery in the backfield. Garcia is a better quarterback than he has shown as of yet. An upgrade over any previous backup the Eagles have had in the past few years, regardless of his early numbers, he proved just that Thursday night. Garcia seemed to have started where he left off against the Raiders, his feet were jittery and he was sacked twice in his first series. After a few plays he seemed to relax and drove the offense on two successful scoring drives, one for a 32 yard touchdown pass to a streaking Darnerien McCants and the other a four yard touchdown run by Thomas Tapah. Garcia ended his night 8 for 11 with 125 yards and one touchdown. Overall Garcia showed much improvement and proved he can still orchestrate an offense effectively.
Andy Reid
During the telecast for the game color analyst, Ron Jaworski said that the Eagles coaching staff prepared for the upcoming season by looking at tapes of how and why they were successful, dating back to five seasons ago. They compared those tapes to ones of the 2005 season to find out exactly what they did wrong to contribute to the “lost” year. Apparently what the coaches saw was that they forgot how to run the ball, because in the past two games, Reid has run the ball excessively and it has worked. Jamming the ball down the throat of opposing defenses was successful on both opening drives of each game and looked smooth and dominating. They kept the steady flow of run plays with a mix of short passes for first downs to march down the field. Any good Army generals consider their battle strategy around their strongest attributes and eliminate their weakest. Using this system of a solid running game mixed with short passes, Reid’s plan will eliminate the need for a “star” receiver and put the effectiveness of the offense in the Eagles strongest points, quick fast backs, a mobile quarterback, a savvy tight end, and a mean offensive line.
Defense
Again the Eagles starting defense looked rugged not giving up any points in their short time playing. Coming into the latter of two games in five days, the defense looked a little out of sorts, getting pushed off the ball by a fresh Cleveland Browns offense in the first series. They eventually stiffened up when it mattered and forced a punt. Darren Howard recorded his first sack of the preseason, making a nice play keeping a grip on a spinning Charlie Frye. Also with a nice play was the almost forgotten Jerome McDougle, who is having a surprisingly good camp, recording his first sack of the pre-season, giving optimism and even more depth to the defensive line. Broderick Bunkley, the Eagles first round pick, played his first pro minutes and was seen smiley and laughing on the sideline as if an enormous weight had been lifted from his shoulders. Bunkley almost recorded a vicious sack when he blew past his blocker and crushed the quarterback a split second after the release. If this show of quickness is Bunkley out of game shape, the Eagles should be secure that the future defense of this team is going to be successful.
Ron Jaworski
Ron Jaworski may be a better football analyst then he was a player, and he was a pretty good player. A major network may want to consider jaws in the booth, he knows football in and out and studies players and teams obsessively before games. A possible replacement for the John Madden? He should at least get a shot.
Thumbs Down
Penalties
Pre-season is made for penalties. Between the young, nervous players fighting for a job, and the working out of kinks in certain areas, what adds to the pre-season being so terribly not watch able are the numerous penalty calls. In the Eagles’ second offensive series they were stopped cold around their own 10 yard line because of flags, and a nice dish pass to LJ Smith for a big gain was called back. This is a cause for concern because discipline is something last years team lacked. But one thing is for sure; if Andy Reid watched the same game everyone else did, those penalties will be gone by the Houston game.
Red Zone Offense
Capping off the first successful drive by the Eagles was a stagnant and gut wrenching failure to get into the end zone from the one yard line A few unsuccessful run attempts by Reno Mahe proved even more that the Eagles need a legitimate short yardage red zone back who can blow a hole open for himself if there isn’t one available.
The Eagles should be able to pick up a big, short yardage back who can hold onto the ball once NFL rosters are cut down. Teams like Tampa Bay, who are already well equipped in that area, should be letting go of some talent.
Overall it was a pretty good showing from the Eagles on both sides of the ball. The special teams continued to look solid and the defense posted more sacks. Luckily the Eagles have been able, so far, to avoid severe injuries in training camp but have suffered a lot of small ones that could come back to haunt the team if the injuries linger. Because of a Brian Westbrook’s foot injury and Bruce Perry’s scary concussion versus the Raiders, Reno Mahe was the starter for this game. He was forced out in the second series due to a concussion which leaves the Eagles and fans wondering; who else do we have? The next Eagles pre-season game is Thursday, August 17th, at 8 p.m. against Steve McNair and the Baltimore Ravens at M&T Bank Stadium in Baltimore.
Photo by Jamie Squire/Getty Images